It also changed how I approached my PhD, my choice of supervisors, and my thoughts on authorship.
Thesis Supervisor "Thank You" Gift?
At the start of the PhD we discussed the issue of authorship of the papers for my PhD and are following the COPE guidelines as we do for the other research we do together. Whilst my topic was my idea, I feel my supervisors have contributed in terms of their guidance and input to meet the requirement for contribution to the conception and design.
We have had productive discussions about the interpretation of findings and they have challenged my thinking to improve those areas. As such I am entirely comfortable that their input should be recognised with authorship. I am the lead author, but their names are on the papers. For me personally, this is important not only in terms of recognising their input but respecting their time and investment in my project.
The publication provides another outcome indicator for their time.
49 Best Thanks Advisors! images | Thank you gifts, Teacher gifts, Appreciation gifts
When supervisors especially associate supervisors who may be ECRs themselves are dependent on those indicators for their own progression, this is more important. There will be papers from the PhD that I will be single author for. On those they will be included in the acknowledgements. I think like all things with a PhD this comes down to the early discussions around expectations, mutual respect, and the quality of supervisors. Kind regards, Erika. While I know some people who have had problems, I had a great experience writing with my supervisor in We really shared a dialogue about what we wanted to say, and after the article was underway, she offered to have it single authored by me if I wished.
When I said I really wanted it to be co-authored because it was! And as a bonus, we are still writing together with another article coming out soon. This is so helpful, thank you! One of my profs has been incredibly supportive in so many ways. Our conversations have enriched my learning and writing. I co-wrote papers with one of my supervisors.
When to Complain?
It was a very worthwhile process in which I learned a lot about how to write for publication. She was an experienced journal editor so was well aware of the pitfalls that authors could avoid. It continues to be a good working relationship post PhD. We have developed a good rapport and I continue to benefit from her experience and advice. Where I work the vast majority do PhDs by publication. There is also an institutional policy that PhD candidates should be the first author on all the published papers in the thesis. What I think is probably most important, though, is that there have been some ir regular meetings where these things have been discussed, both in supervisor only groups, and in mixed groups with supervisors and candidates.
When I did my PhD I wrote the first article with my supervisor and it was an invaluable learning experience.
Pingback: co-writing with your supervisor — do we need a code of good practice? In my opinion, it depends on the Institution, programme and country. I have had a troubling relationship with my main supervisor which ended in my decision to end the supervision with her and I got a new and great supervisor as a replacement.bilwaberiseb.ml
PhD Discussion Forum
In the end, it turned out that they are both co-authors on all my articles for my PhD. I have felt this unfair at times and thought of them both as free-riders, particularly because I have collected all data by myself and worked very independently. But then I have come to terms with this because:. As such, I might not be dependent on being single-author for future jobs.
Even if the relationship had worked well, co-authorship shows that you can do teamwork. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account. You are commenting using your Twitter account. You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. RSS - Posts.
Skip to content. Home about me my research my books contributions and comments talks and workshops.
- Completion seminar.
- telephony research papers.
- What should you give your PhD supervisor for Christmas?.
- book report of harry potter and the chamber of secrets.
- Cheap labour.
- Ethical guidelines?
- argumentative essay on dr jekyll and mr hyde;
Like this: Like Loading This entry was posted in authorship , co-writing , supervisor , Uncategorized and tagged academic writing , co-writing , Pat Thomson , supervision , writing with your supervisor. Bookmark the permalink. April 10, at am. Brenda Like Like. Thomson says:. Tom says:. Tom Like Like. April 10, at pm.
The Protocol states: The ICMJE recommends that authorship be based on the following 4 criteria: Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work; AND Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content; AND Final approval of the version to be published; AND Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.
Best wishes, David Like Liked by 1 person. Erika Langham says:. April 11, at am. Kind regards, Erika Like Like. Adam Barker says:.
Nan says:. Carmel Capewell says:. April 12, at am. Hege says:. On the other hand, maybe this situation makes you consider a question all the researchers contemplate sooner or later: are you ready to manage without an academic supervisor and start researching on your own? Leave A Reply Cancel Reply. Subscribe for free to get unrestricted access to all our resources on research writing and academic publishing including:. We hate spam too.
We promise to protect your privacy and never spam you. Student—advisor relationship. Last updated May 21, 0. Leave A Reply. You've exhausted your free articles.